Surge in NMC Investigations following the Lucy Letby conviction

Surge in NMC Investigations

In the aftermath of the shocking Lucy Letby story, the regulatory landscape for nursing and midwifery is experiencing an alarming increase in fitness to practise (FtP) referrals and enquiries. Monthly cases have reached an all-time high, with the Nursing and Midwifery Council (NMC) receiving 578 FtP referrals in September alone – a staggering 34% higher than anticipated and bringing the FtP caseload to a daunting 5,500, as disclosed in recently published council papers.

The NMC, acknowledging the uphill battle it faces, admitted during a recent governing council meeting that it will fall short of its target to resolve 4,000 cases by the end of the financial year. However, a firm commitment to reducing the backlog persists, despite the challenging circumstances.

Lesley Maslen, executive director of professional regulation, shared with the Nursing Times that the NMC is navigating a delicate balance between ambitious transformation goals and the stark realities on the ground. In a meeting held today, the NMC revealed a lack of a conclusive pattern in the surge of referrals. Still, some council members hinted at the potential impact of recent events, particularly the Letby conviction, which sentenced her to life in prison for the murder of seven babies and the attempted murder of six others.

The FtP hearing for Lucy Letby is scheduled for December 2023 at the NMC headquarters, with the only possible outcome being one of being struck off. While the driving forces behind the surge in referrals remain unclear, council papers unveiled that the Letby conviction sparked a notable increase in enquiries to the NMC.

This sentiment was echoed by Lesley Maslen during the council meeting, where she highlighted that trusts had reached out to the NMC regarding internal matters related to incidents involving staff since the Letby conviction. The confluence of events, including the Letby case, has created what Ms. Maslen described as a “perfect storm” for the NMC, exacerbated by recent headlines and controversies.

September brought further challenges with the announcement of an investigation into the NMC’s handling of FtP and whistleblowing. Allegations surfaced earlier in the year, claiming the prioritisation of speed over thoroughness in a bid to reduce the FtP backlog. Additionally, a reported “culture of fear” within the organization hindered staff from speaking up.

Important Note for Professionals Facing NMC Investigation

If you find yourself referred to the NMC for an investigation, seeking early legal advice is crucial. Regulation Resolution understands the complexities of such situations and can offer a free case assessment with no obligation to instruct us. This assessment will provide you with insights into the seriousness of the concerns and practical tips to assist you during this challenging time. Your proactive approach to legal support can make a significant difference in navigating the intricacies of the NMC investigation process.  Do contact us for a free case evaluation